Bring the ALP back to reality

By Rob Quinn

If the present mess is continued then the Party, (but not its ideals), may come close to extinction.

I see the problem as a ‘stick in the mud’ Party leadership, who have bent only a little towards the path of reform. If they are on a ‘good thing’, their thinking is, probably to stay with it, i.e. preserve the present Party structure which makes sure that they remain in control with access to future seats in the NSW MLC and the Australian Senate.

A suggestion as to a solution to the above would be for all Party members to be allocated a P.I.N. number with their annual membership card. This PIN could be used to vote for replacement candidates for such positions as a membership of the NSW Legislative Council, especially for Labor MLC members who retire before their full term. Prospective ALP replacement candidates could be invited to post a brief summary of their credentials on-line, with policies, and reasons for election for all NSW ALP members to see.

Members could then vote using their PIN. Members without computer access to the internet, or who are unfamiliar with computer use, could be given the names and addresses of local members prepared to help them lodge their vote.

This could be summarised as “e-membership” and “e-democracy”. To make sure of the workings of such a system a pilot programme could be carried out in a selected region, may I suggest my own region of Gilmore, and any faults or failings could be fixed before the system is made NSW wide.

The possibilities are great. Candidates pushing policies would be able to travel to different Party units speaking and discussing all matters prior to the vote being taken.

Determination would be needed by all sides to get the idea up and running. The present Party leadership would need to be dragged along to agree with the above.

The present protests of the membership seeking a more democratic Party structure will no doubt, continue for a long time. Will these protests simply be ‘hot air’ which can be easily ignored by the present Party leadership? The above idea of “e-membership” is one part of a suggested solution.

Forming committees and having forums and bus trips for solutions to Party problems can be largely a waste of time if the few same faces are the only ones to attend.

Politics is the art of the possible. Electronic voting by a mass membership has a very good chance of re-making our ALP.

Posted in Misc | Leave a comment

OurALP Activist meeting report for 24th July.

There was a meeting of Our ALP activists two weeks back, at Leichhardt Town Hall, with people dialing in from other parts of NSW and overseas.

The meeting agreed that the reforms secured at State Conference don’t go as far as they should, that they are only one step in the right direction, and that what matters most is developing a culture of insisting that, for example, rules be respected.

It was agreed that having a loose structure has had advantages, but that there would be value in adopting a formal structure, if we can find the right mechanisms for selecting official spokespeople, etc, possibly a mechanism based on formal affiliations by branches. A subcommittee will be formed to prepare a proposal for wider consideration.

It was agreed that Our ALP does not have a platform beyond our shared objective of “increased power for members though democratic reform”.  It was agreed that we would not endorse candidates for Public Office or a Policy Committee, and we would endorse candidates for committees like Rules only if we have candidates we trust.

It was agreed in principle to have an event in October, possibly with the purpose of supporting the 2010 Review Recommendations at National Conference, possibly a formation meeting. A subcommittee will be formed to prepare a proposal for wider consideration.

It was agreed that a 3 or 5 person editorial board will be selected to make decisions about what can and can’t go onto ouralp.net – membership and processes to be decided at the next meeting. In the interim, posting will be managed by Ben Aveling, Marcus Strom, Darcy Byrne and Chris Simpson.

It was agreed to have monthly phone hookups, the next one perhaps the weekend of the 21st Aug – date to be confirmed.  It was agreed that some of these meetings will be held outside Sydney subject to cost and availability of teleconference facilities.
Posted in Misc | Leave a comment

Admin Committee and Rules Committee

This is unofficial, but the new Administrative Committee is (in ballot paper order):
Right: Mark Lennon, Gerald Dwyer, Kirsten Andrews, Wayne Forno, Prue Guillaume, Barbara Nebart, Graeme Kelly, Tony Sheldon, Mark Ptolemy, Russ Collison, Julie Sibraa, Alex Classens, Jim Metcher, Kate Washington, Davina Langton
Left: Jan Primrose, Mal Tulloch, Sally McManus, Grahame Kelly, Sharon Claydon, Anthony D’Adam, Jenny McAllister, Tim Ayers, Geoff Derrick, Rita Mallia

The Rules Committee is (in ballot paper order):
Right: Katie Ford, Michael Buckland, Amanda Fazio, Wayne Meaney, Rob Allen, Talal Yassine
Left: Peter Primrose, Jan Burnswoods, Anthony D’Adam

Posted in NSW ALP State Conference | Tagged , | 1 Comment

Conference Report for Day 2

Yesterday started with the Country Labor report.

There was a lot of anger at Rodney Cavalier’s comments of the day before (“Amanda Fazio talked about us wiping out Country Labor. Well the electorate just did.  Having the country electorates represented here is an act of charity.”).  There was a sense that city people don’t understand the challenges faced in the country, for example, Michael McManus observed that: “some of our electorates have 80+ booths, some as small as 30 people”.  There was also some recognition that Cavalier perhaps had half a point, given that our primary vote was under 10% in many seats.

There was a fair degree of discussion about whether Country Conference should be allowed to elect, for example, the Country Organiser. Matt Martin moved an amendment, which was accepted, that Country Conference should discuss the issue and make a recommendation to be voted on at the next State Conference.

That was followed by John Watkins and Anthony Chisholm presenting their report, which also sparked much comment.

Paul Howes seemed happy to lead the ‘change nothing’ case, basically arguing that the general public  are only concerned with policies and leadership, not with the process that generates them.  Other people argued that it’s not possible to separate the two, that our policies and leaders are a direct result of the way we do business.

Marcus Strom asked why the the Watkins/Chisholm report wasn’t released before the rules debate.

Johno Johnson proposed cutting membership fees to $20, and noted that this would be a considerable saving to many sitting MPs.

As with the country report, there were lots of good comments and interesting comments, but it wasn’t really a debate because there wasn’t much back and forth – just lots of comments.

The afternoon saw the presentation of life-memberships, more reports and and a range of topics spoken to.

Perhaps the most notable topic was same-sex marriage. After a great deal of backroom discussion on the topic, no conclusion was reached. Instead of an agreement on the issue, or a vote, there was agreement only to refer the issue to Federal Conference, and let them make a decision.

The returning officer didn’t get to speak until very late in the day.  The Left contested but did not win the positions of president, general secretary; state organiser, and organiser, communications and training.  Chris Quilkey and Maurice May were successful in their bid for places as National Conference Delegates.  Neither Chris Quilkey nor Neil Reilly nor I were successful in our bid for places on Admin/Rules, though I understand that Admin was close enough to ‘give them a scare’ – it took about four hours of counting before the final results were clear.

You can see the twitter hashtag #nswalp11 for more details.

Overall, a lot of people are a bit glass-half-empty about the reforms – good but would have been nice to have been better.

Personally, I’m more glass-half-full.  Lots of loopholes remain, but some have been closed and others tightened.

Where the rank and file are vigilant, these reforms will help in preventing the sort of abuses that have too often been the norm. In electorates where the rank and file are not prepared to act, nothing is going to change.

Posted in NSW ALP State Conference | 5 Comments

Conference Report for Day 1.

Julia Gillard, Robbo, Dastyari, John Graham all spoke to Conference and all of them said that reform was essential, as did a range of the other speakers – even as they disagreed about what reforms they wanted to see.

Nathan Rees was present, and said to Channel 9 that  Labor can’t win until it reforms

The OurALP Fringe event was well attended and Bob Carr was very well received.

But the absolute highlight of the day was that we got a good chunk of what we wanted. It’s not perfect. There are still loopholes and the Rank and File will need to be vigilant to ensure that these loopholes are not exploited. But it’s still an enormous step forwards. See below for details.

Ballots for Admin and Rules and National Conference and the other committees are today. Neil Reilly and Chris Quilkey are the only candidates for running for Admin that are not  on a factional ticket. Running for Rules: Chris Quilkey, Ben Aveling and one other. Running for National Conference: Chris Quilkey and Maurice May. The Right have put the independant candidates last, behind the Left. The Left have not made a recommendation as to how preferences are to be distributed.

Anyone wanting a blow by blow account is invited to check out the twitter stream #nswalp11 (http://twitter.com/#search?q=%23nswalp)

Intervention only in exceptional circumstances

Was:

N.40 The Administrative Committee can, in consultation with the Parliamentary Leadership and the local Electorate Council, decide to hold a ballot under the provisions of this rule;
(a) in the case of the State By-election unless determined otherwise by the Joint Campaign Committee or,
(b) in case of any other by-elections; or
(c) if an endorsed candidate needs to be selected while the Party is on a campaign footing, as determined by the Administrative Committee; or
(d) in other urgent situations, as recommended by the Party Officers and with the leave of the Administrative Committee.
If this happens the candidate will be selected by a Committee made up of equal numbers from the Administrative Committee, and where practicable, the Local Electorate Council. The Committee’s candidate will become the endorsed Labor candidate.

Now:

N.40 The Administrative Committee may, in consultation with the Parliamentary Leadership and the local Electorate Council, conduct a selection for public office pursuant to the provisions of this Rule:
(i) in the case of a State By-election unless determined otherwise by the Joint Campaign Committee or,
(ii) in case of any other by-election; or
(iii) In exceptional circumstances

Where the Administrative Committee decides to conduct a selection for public office under this Rule, the candidate will be selected by a Committee made up of equal numbers from the Administrative Committee and the Local Electorate Council. The Committee’s candidate will become th eendorsed Labor candidate.

Timing of preselections

Was:

Nominations will be called, where practicable, at least one year before a General Election is expected. If necessary, for example, if there is a redistribution of electorates, nominations can be reopened and the Administrative Committee shall call for fresh nominations.

Now:

Nominations will be called at least one year before a General Election is expected unless there are exceptional circumstances that justify acting otherwise. If necessary, for example, if there is a redistribution of electorates, nominations can be reopened and the Administrative Committee shall call for fresh nominations.

Increase accountability by requiring proof for concessional membership

New rule

Members applying to join at a concessional rate must provide proof of their entitlement to this concessional rate. The Administrative Committee may by resolution establish levels of documentation required to support a claim of entitlement to the concessaionl rate and processes to ensure compliance with this rule.

direct election of union delegates

Neil Reilly and Chris Quilkey moved a motion of in-principle support for union members having the right to choose whether or not not they want to elect their delegates directly, as well as tightening some other loop holes (may -> shall, remove the option for people to bulk enroll other people, add a definition of exceptional circumstances, preselections to be called 12 months in advance, add a recourse if preselections are not called 12 months in advance, in-principle support for the public parts of the 2010 review)

Direct elections of party officers/Legislative Council

There was a lot of vitriol thrown on these topics – but I think that only amendment on the topic was “local determination of some National Conference delegates”, which got up. Bascially, each FEC gets to appoint one National conference delegate, with the remainder to be appointed by Conference. FECs are encouraged but not required to have that election be a direct election.

Publication of secretaries contact details

Darcy Byrne and ? Christodoulou moved a motion that Secretaries contact details should be available. The motion received a fair bit of support but failed on a show of hands.

Amanda Fazio said that headoffice will circulate material to branch secretaries if asked, on a monthly basis.

Policy Forum

There is to be a new mechanism for generating policy – broadly speaking, it sounds like there will be working groups to produce reports (and there can be minority reports issued) and reports will then be sent to State Parliamentary Labor Party and/or Conference for endorsement.

Preselections
The trial of 5 in 2015 is going ahead – exact mix, whether 60/20/20 or 50/50 or something else is still TBD and may be different in different electorates.

Online policy branch

There will be an experiment with an online policy branch – no preselection rights attached.

Posted in NSW ALP State Conference | 1 Comment

Rules Report Amendments

The following amendments to the Rules Report were submitted earlier today. Continue reading

Posted in NSW ALP State Conference | 1 Comment

An open letter to Sam Dastyari by Bill Mallam

Dear Sam,

Our family have been lifelong members of the ALP. My father Cliff Mallam was a member for 76 years and a State Member of Parliament for 28 years. I have been a member for 48 years. My son Nick is also a member. As a Life Member I have worked for the party at every Council, State and Federal election for over 50 years.

My ability to influence party decisions on policy and candidate pre-selection have in recent years been rendered almost non existent.

Upper House pre-selections should be subject to a State wide vote of ALP members. There could be exceptions where a member resigns unexpectedly and a replacement is needed urgently due to close numbers in the house.

Lower House pre-selections should be put to a ballot of ALP members residing in the relevant electorate as soon as practicable after a member resigns. My father won the seat of Campbelltown from the Liberal party in 1971 and would turn in his grave to see the events that occurred after the resignation of Graeme West which resignation occurred over six months before the State election.

It is apparent that the proposed trial candidate pre-selection process to be put before the State Conference will allow members of the public, not even members of the party, to have a vote in pre-selections.

I will be forced to reconsider my membership if, as I suspect, the proposed reforms to be put before the July State Conference of the party do not deliver genuine reform.

At the very least I will resign as the Secretary and Treasurer of the Wollondilly Branch if ALP rank and file members are not given more power to influence pre-selections and decision making processes within the party.

Yours faithfully,

Bill Mallam
21/06/2011

Posted in Misc | Leave a comment

Candidate Profile – Maurice May – National Conference Delegate

By Maurice May
I am a life member of the party. I believe that it is important for the conference of the New South Wales branch to elect delegates to the National conference who are prepared to put forward ideas that may not necessarily accord with the views of the major factions.
I am not a member of any faction.

The issues which the National conference must deal with are in my view the following:

  1. It must allow same sex marriages to be recognised.
  2. We must withdraw our troops from Iraq and Afghanistan.
  3. The caucus must have its right to elect ministers restored.

I am a candidate for a position of delegate to the National conference and I seek your support.

Maurice May

Posted in NSW ALP State Conference | Leave a comment

An open letter from the rank and file

Dear Delegate,

Re: Reform or Revolt

As you know, the decisions that you make at NSW Labor’s 2011 state conference will have an enormous impact on the future of our party and our movement in this State.

The reform proposals supported by the rules committee, for a limited trial of community preselections in three years time and a new policy forum are positive, but they do not go anywhere near far enough. These proposals provide no road map at all for how to halt and reverse the devastating shrinking and ageing of our membership base over the next three years.

An overwhelming number of motions from local branches, that delegates will consider, support a move toward increased direct election of positions by party members.

Given this, if conference chooses not to endorse any increased powers for members, it will be an unmistakeable repudiation of the will of our party’s rank and file.

You should know that such a snub has the potential to provoke rank and file members across the state into a campaign of open revolt against the party’s current hierarchy.

If members’ positive and constructive reform proposals are not supported, we will have no choice but to continue our campaign for reform and renewal so that in twelve months time we are in a position to elect a majority of delegates who are willing to represent the views of members rather than the power brokers.

Yours sincerely,
Alex Lofts – Ashfield Councillor, Liam Hogan – Stanmore Camperdown Branch, Linda Scott – Erskinville Branch, Dinesh Gonsalkorale – Ashfield Branch, Tom Harris-Brassil – Stanmore Camperdown Branch, Amanda Rose – Dulwich Hill / Lewisham Branch, James Still – Darlington Branch, Mary O’Sullivan – Marrickville Councillor, Darcy Byrne – Leichhardt Councillor, Ben Karalus – Leichhardt Branch President, Michael Johnson – Summer Hill Branch, Laurie Urane – Haberfield Branch, Lucille McKenna – Ashfield Councillor, Jerry Stiel – Annandale Branch, Gemma Haigh – Warren Branch, Jack McBride – Balmain Branch, Jo Blackman – Dulwich Hill / Lewisham Branch, Imogen Wareing – Earlwood Branch, Seumas Phelan – Ashbury Branch, Damien Hogan – Balmain SEC Secretary, Richard Walsham – Marrickville SEC Secretary, Victoria Rollison – Alexandria Branch, Lliam Caulfield – Warren Branch, Susan Martin – Balmain Branch, Susan Lever – Erskinville Branch, Catherine Crittenden – Summer Hill Branch, Marcus Strom – Sumer Hill Branch, Ian Peel – Marrickville Central Branch, Michael Butterworth – Ryde Councillor, Tom Flood – South West Rocks FEC, and Keith Perkins Dubbo Branch Secretary, Glenda Gartrell – Willoughby branch, Pamela Slater – Berowra / Mt Colah Branch, Kathryn Landsberry – Kogorah Councillor, Diane O’Brien – Ryde Branch, Michelle Cahill, Willoughby branch, Denis O’Connell – Ryde Branch, Richard Slater – Mt. Colah/Berowra Branch President, Edna Wilson – Balmain Branch, Don McGregor – Katoomba Branch President, Tanya Jackson Vaughan Dulwich Hill / Lewisham Branch President, Simon Crittle – Balmain Branch Secretary, Philip Smyth – Leichhardt Branch, Steve Storey – Fivedock, John Fryer – Ryde Branch, Judy Singer – Balmain Branch, Shane McArdle – Warren Branch , John Diplock – Summer Hill Branch, Yang Ding – NSW Young Labor Executive, Phil Drew – Leichhardt Branch, Brian Frankham – Balmain Branch, Bob Burford – Annandale Branch, Dorethy Burwood – Annandale Branch, Nizza Siano, Vaucluse SEC President, James Du Pre Dungog Branch, Tom Zelinka Annandale Branch, Harry Johnson – Rozelle/Lilyfield Branch, Lorre Manning – Morisset Branch Secretary, Sasha Blumen, Kings Cross Branch, Tom Hall – Summer Hill branch, Anna Beresford – Summer Hill branch. Ruark Lewis – Paddington Branch, Adrian Wong – Secretary Cabramatta SEC Secretary, Stephanie Cunio – Double Bay/Bellevue Hill Branch, Eric Snowball Glebe Branch President, George Cooper Balmain Branch, Neil Reilly – Kiama Councillor, Ed Gilmore – Kiama Branch, Gordon Mackay – Kiama Branch, John McCutcheon – Kiama Branch, Simon Mansfieild Kiama Branch, Virginia Walker – Fivedock Branch & Inaugural McKell Award winner, Paul Pearce – Bronte Branch President, Ingrid Strewe Bronte Branch Secretary, Carmel Niland Double Bay Bellevue Hill Branch President, Mary Hunt – Double Bay / Bellevue Hill Branch, Chris Hunt – Double Bay / Bellevue Hill Branch, Alan Outhred – Summer Hill Branch, Glenn Holdstock – Summer Hill Branch, Anthony McLaughlin – Kings Cross Branch, John Wakefield – Waverly Councillor, Ivan Ransom – Balmain Branch, Sacha Blumen – Kings Cross Branch, Mark Drury – Ashfield Councillor, Steve Hambridge – Balmain Branch, Narelle Callanan – Bondi Beach Branch President, Jenny Haines – Newtown Golden Grove Branch, Neil O’Hare – Bondi Beach Branch Secretary, Linda Beattie – Neutral Bay Branch, Chris Simpson – Willoughby Branch President, Rachael Simpson – Willoughby Branch, Tom Westbrook – Willoughby Branch, Nick Wright – Willoughby Branch Secretary, Justin Holmwood – Mt Colah/Berowra Branch Secretary, Andria Kannane – Willoughby branch, Robbie Wilde – Katoomba Branch, Shirley Ross-Shuley – Katoomba Branch, Brian Kirkby – Mid Mountains Branch, Samantha Thompson – Mid Mountains Branch, Verity Williams Katoomba Branch, John Harper – Darling Harbour Branch, Chris Quilkey – Quakers Hill Branch Secretary, Mick Fell – Springwood Branch, Richard Collier – Springwood Branch, Richard Bournes – Springwood Branch, Annie Hearn – Springwood Branch , Pam Crafoord – Springwood Branch, Martin McLaren – Springwood Branch, Colleen Carmody – Springwood Branch, Bernard McNair – Springwood Branch, Chris Dunstan – Dulwich Hill / Lewishan Branch, Luther Weate – Paddington Branch

Posted in Misc | Leave a comment

Rank and file members demand ALP reform

By ALP Sydney State Electorate Council
Rank and file ALP members have demanded the upcoming NSW ALP conference, to be held 9-10 July 2011, support real party reform.
A meeting of rank and file ALP members, held on 27 June 2011 at the Unions NSW building in Sydney, endorsed key recommendations of the 2010 ALP National Review that party officers and a portion of the ALP National Conference be directly elected by party members. Nearly 100 rank and file members attended the meeting, which was organised by the ALP Sydney State Electoral Council.
David Carey, President of the ALP Sydney State Electoral Council, said “Rank and file ALP members have strongly endorsed the direct election of Federal and State ALP Presidents. They also supported local rank and file preselections of candidates occurring without interference from the NSW ALP or National Executive and have demanded greater democratic participation in the ALP.”
Mr Carey also said that there was a risk the NSW ALP conference would make only minor reforms to the party, ignoring the concerns of rank and file members. “The NSW ALP conference will consider motions for party reform from branches across the state. Rank and file members must be heard.”

Motion carried at the 27 June 2011 meeting of rank and file ALP members at the Unions NSW building in Sydney

This meeting supports the 2010 National Review conducted by former Premiers Steve Bracks, Bob Carr and Senator John Faulkner as an important statement of the views of Party members on the need for reform of the Labor Party.
In particular, this meeting endorses the call for greater democratic participation in the Labor Party contained in the Review recommendation, especially the recommendations relating to the direct election of National Conference delegates, and direct election of state and territory presidencies.
The meeting notes and supports the call for the preselection rights of local members to be respected, without interference or intervention from the NSW Head Office or the National Executive.
The meeting recognises the need to try new and creative ways to engage with the 5 million voters who continue to loyally support the Labor Party in general elections but who are not members of the ALP.
The meeting also calls on delegates to the NSW state Conference to support farreaching reform of Labor in this state, and to put the Party’s interests ahead of their factional interests by supporting a free vote on all matters of Party reform at the Conference.
That this motion be referred to all NSW State Conference delegates.

Posted in Misc | Leave a comment