How Stuff Works – The (NSW) Labor Party – Part 1, Party Units

Technically speaking, the NSW Labor Party is structured as a representative democracy. In practice, outcomes are generally undemocratic for reasons examined below.

The structure in other states is broadly similar, with a range of variations, especially around numbers and ratios.

Party Units

Party Units

 

State Conference:

The ‘supreme decision making body’, only Conference has the power to change the rules of the Party or the Policy Platform. Conference appoints the Administrative Committee, the Party Officers (General Secretary, 2 Assistant Secretaries, and President and 3 Vice Presidents), delegates to Federal Conference, members of Machinery Committees, members of Policy Committees and candidates for the NSW Legislative Council (the NSW upper house).
Conference is composed of around 800 delegates, 50% of whom come from Afilliated Unions, around 100 delegates appointed through a range of mechanisms (16 from Young Labor, 16 to represent Federal Parliamentarians, 16 to represent State Parliamentarians, the 35 member Administrative Committee and 3 from each Policy Committe and 3 from the women’s Committee) and the remainder from State and Federal Electoral Councils. Enough Conference Delegates are members of a faction that Conference outcomes are all but totally determined by the factions.

Administrative Committee:

Also known as Admin, the Administrative Committee directs the Party between Conferences. It has most of the powers of Conference and is more important because it meets every month whilst Conference meets only once a year.
The Administrative Committee is composed of 35 members, of whom 25 are directly selected by Conference, plus the 7 Party Officers (as above), plus the State and Federal Parliamentary Leaders, plus, in a non-voting capacity, a member of Young Labor, normally the President. These 35 people are sometimes known as the ‘faceless men’, not because their identity is secret but because it is not publicised and the legwork required to identify them is beyond the ability of most Australian journalists.
The NSW Administrative Committee is totally factionalised. Committee members are either factional heavy weights or are appointed by factional heavyweights. In theory, there are be enough non-factionally alligned delegates at conference for this not to be the case, but in NSW the non-factional delegates do not vote in a sufficient block to elect any Administrative Committee Members.

Electoral Councils:

There is a State Electoral Council (SEC) for each State Electorate, a Federal Electorate Council (FEC) for each Federal Electoral Council, and a Local Government Committee for each Local Government Area. Each SEC sends 2 delegates to State Conference and each FEC sends 3 delegates to State Conference. LGCs are not represented at Conference.
Electoral Councils are composed of delegates from Branches. The size of an Electoral Council is determined by the number and size of the local branches. While the degree of factionalisation in Electoral Counciles varies, Council Executives are predominately faction members.

Branches:

Branches represent an area which can be as small as a single suburb or as large as a whole Electorate (in which case the Branch acts as the Electoral Council and is known as an Electoral Branch). Each Branch sends a number of delegates to each of its local Electoral Councils, depending on the size of the branch, and depending on whether a branch straddles an electorate boundary.
Branches are composed of party members. Most members will attend their nearest branch but members may attend any branch in their State Electorate. Regular attendance at a branch is a prerequiste for participation in preselections. Most branch members are not members of a faction, but Branch Executives are disproportionately factionalised.

Affiliated Unions:

Not all Unions are affiliated. Non affiliated unions play no structural role in the ALP. Affiliated Unions send a number of delegates to conference, depending on the size of the union’s membership. There is no restriction on how a Union chooses its delegates. In practice, most unions delegates are selected by the union secretary, meaning that delegates represent the interests of the Union secretariate first, and ordinary union members second, if at all. Many union delegates are not members of the union they nominally represent. Many union members do not even realise that they are ‘represented’ at Conference.

The Rank and File:

The expression ‘Rank and File’ normally refers either to all Party Members, or to all Party Members plus  all members of Affiliated Unions, depending on context.

It is still common, if less so than it used to be, for a person to both a party member and a union member.

Factions:

Factions are not formally part of the structure of the Labor Party, but their members compose a percentage of all party units, most especially the higher echelons. In a self-reinforcing pattern, factions are able to determine the outcome of most significant decisions, which means that they are able to command the loyalty of their members, and generally above and beyond loyalty to the rank and file. Because the main source of information about happenings higher up the structure is the delegates themselves, this conflict of interest is only rarely visible to those below. Because this dilution of democracy is repeated at every level of the structure, alignment between the rank and file and the Administrative Committee is effectively non-existent. Most of the Rank and File do not realise that they, indirectly, choose the Administrative Committee, or even that it exists.

Advertisements
This entry was posted in Inward Correspondence. Bookmark the permalink.

8 Responses to How Stuff Works – The (NSW) Labor Party – Part 1, Party Units

  1. Damien says:

    Where do the policy committees fit into this picture? Do they still exist, and do they play any role?

    • Ben Aveling says:

      They still exist. The feedback I’ve received from someone on one of them suggests that they may not play much role any more.

  2. Paul Jones says:

    Do we (ie someone) know who the 35 members of the Administrative Committee are ? If it is not meant to be a secret, then making this list known would be a good step for transparency.

  3. Ali says:

    This is a really good picture of how it all works, especially on affiliated unions. I doubt most young retail workers even know they are members of the SDA ditto a few other unions. Nor would they know that they are ‘represented’ at conference opposing gay marriage or other progressive motions. I think you will find that they Admin Committee is made up largely of right faction union secretaries, but it’s a good point, why is it top secret. Could it be because they frequently make decisions against the interests of their members? Could it be because they put faction first against the interests of their members? Could it be they have one eye on their own tilt at preselection, board position or other reward against the interests of their members?

    • Ben Aveling says:

      The following people were elected to Admin in 2008.

      Alex Bukarica (Miners, Left)
      Anne Purcell
      Anne Thompson
      Anthony D’Adam (Left)
      Ben Kruse
      Geoff Derrick (FSU, Left)
      Gerard Dwyer
      Jan Primrose (Left)
      Jenny McAllister (Left, Federal Vice President)
      Jim Lloyd
      Jim Metcher
      Joanne Morris
      John Robertson
      Julie Sibraa
      Kaye Simmons
      Mark Ptolemy (NUW, Right)
      Michael Want
      Michelle Rowland
      Nick Lewocki
      Paul Bastian
      Russ Collison (AWU, Right)
      Sally McManus (ASU)
      Sharon Claydon (Left)
      Tara Moriarty (Junior Vice President)
      Tony Sheldon (Right)

      In addition, there are a number of people who are on Admin because of some other position they hold:

      Sam Dastyari, General Secretary, Right
      Chris Minns, Right Asst. General Secretary
      John Graham, Left Asst. General Secretary

      Michael Lee, President
      Michael Williamson, Senior Vice President
      Mark Boyd, ALP Junior Vice President (LHMU)

      I have been told that Paul Bastian has since resigned from Admin. There have been other changes as well, including some departures, and the addition of:
      Kirsten Andrews
      Mark Lennon (Right)
      Rita Mallia (Left)
      Rob Allen
      Sam Moreton
      Tim Ayres

  4. Alix says:

    Hi Ben, who was elected at conference this weekend just gone?

  5. Alix says:

    Hi Ben,

    Thanks for your response. Really the key to cracking the Admin Committee is the union affiliation numbers. I see a few union folk are posting here and feel a bit wounded. Why don’t they add to the transparency they claim to want and reveal the numbers that they affiliate on. I quite naively stumbled onto this issue a few years ago when as a conference delegate from my branch I got the affiliation numbers, they were way above the numbers declared on the audit (this was a union I was a member of and quite involved with) and well above the numbers on the ballot roll in the election (I think it was around 2007 maybe 2006). Having talked to a few people who set me straight about how this works I have to say I was shocked. The union really was just an ATM for the ALP through thousands of dollars in over affiliation + the numbers and power that buys. An ordinary ALP member has no hope against such bastardry. I ask the question again, are the affiliation numbers revealed? Can any member call Sussex Street and get them? Does the ALP do any sort of audit of the numbers declared by affiliates? These are of course rhetorical questions, I already know the answers as do the union officials posting here.

  6. Pingback: How to change policy in the NSW ALP (part 1) | Our ALP

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s